Welcome to Cruise Talk the Internet's most popular discussion forum dedicated to cruising. Stop by Cruise Talk anytime to post a message or find out what your fellow passengers and industry insiders are saying about a particular ship, cruise line or destination.
>>> Reader Reviews >>> CruisePage.com Photo Gallery >>> Join Our Cruise Club.
Latest News...Norwegian Cruise Line celebrated the debut of the all-new Norwegian Aqua to Port Canaveral, Fla. on Saturday, April 26, 2025, where she commenced her inaugural season of round-trip Caribbean cruises as the newest ship in port. This past weekend, approximately 3,700 guests embarked on Norwegian Aqua's first week-long voyage to the Caribbean from Port Canaveral, Fla., her initial homeport ...
Latest News...Royal Caribbean Group (NYSE: RCL) today reported first quarter Earnings per Share ("EPS") of $2.70 and Adjusted EPS of $2.71. These results were better than the company's guidance due to stronger than expected pricing on close-in demand and lower costs mainly due to timing. Royal Caribbean said that it is increasing its full year 2025 Adjusted EPS guidance to $14.55 to $15.55...
Latest News...Holland America Line announced itineraries for its two Grand Voyages sailing in 2027, offering guests the choice to embark on an ambitious 129-day circumnavigation of the globe on the 2027 Grand World Voyage or a 70-day, region-specific in-depth exploration on the Grand South America & Antarctica Voyage. As revealed today by the cruise line's president Beth Bodensteiner to guests on board...
The Northrop Grumman Ingalls shipyard in Pascagoula in Mississippi has resumed work on the $459m Project America cruiseship that was abandoned last October after the collapse of American Classic Voyages, and is preparing to float the semi-finished vessel out this autumn after closing a sale. Unofficial information from Pascagoula identifies Star Cruises subsidiary Norwegian Cruise Line as a strong contender to buy the semi-finished cruiseship and its yet to be assembled sister vessel. It is understood the owner would take the hulls to Europe for completion. Lloyd Werft has been mentioned by sources in Pascagoula as the European destination for the hulls, a theory fitting in with the yard’s ship-lengthening experience with NCL. NCL parent Star Cruises is known to have been nurturing $450m plans for two new ships and is said to be in negotiations with Meyer Werft. The first Ingalls ship is about 40% complete and about 55% erected. Mr Knecht said the yard would add “just enough” to float it out. Work on the second ship has not started. But he said 90% of the raw material, including hull blocks and equipment, was already on order.
Ryndam
I am saddened to see these ships going to a foreign registry after all .
However, NCL are in tremendous need of new tonnage, as are Star. They could very likely finish these ships to their own specifications, and buy new ships from Meyer Werft.
NCL has had very good experiences at Lloyd Werft rebuilding the unfinished CostaOlympia hull into Norwegian Sky (a very similar project to this one), stretching Dreamward and Windward and refitting them to become Norwegian Dream and Wind, stretching and refitting Norwegian Majesty, doing all of the refits for Norway over the years, and last but certianly not least, building Norwegian Sun. I would expect that there is quite a rapport between the two companies.
Happy Cruising,Cruiseny
Anyway, if NCL does take the hulls I hope they do some serious redesigns- those two ships were by far the ugliest designs in decades- and was pleased to see construction stopped.
I was just wondering where you read about NCL/Project America. I have not seen anything anywhere, and I always love good new sources...
Thad
From Seatrader:
Is Project America headed for Europe?10/06/02
Northrup Grumman is actively marketing the two Project America ships that have been languishing at Ingalls since the October bankruptcy of American Classic Voyages. Some 350 workers are preparing the first newbuild, which is 40% completed, to be launched from its assembly area in September, spokesman Den Knecht told Seatrade Insider. Most equipment for the second ship has been ordered but assembly was never begun.
According to a knowledgeable industry source not associated with the yard, preparations are also underway to reclassify the first ship and tow it to Europe for completion. `A shipyard like Lloyd Werft or B+V could put it together in less than 18 months,' he said. While Knecht would not discuss Ingalls' asking price for the newbuild norpublished reports putting the figure at $36m, the industry source told Seatrade Insider: `Nobody believes they'll get less than $50m.'
Knecht would not comment on a report that Norwegian Cruise Line or parent company Star are among the interested buyers for one or both of the 72,000gt, 1,900-passenger newbuilds, and NCL president Colin Veitch also declined to address the topic. Knecht said only that there are `several interested parties.'
MARAD has a lien on Project America but Ingalls holds the title. After MARAD rejected bids tendered at an auction held last month, it asked the shipbuilder to unilaterally seek a buyer.
[ 06-11-2002: Message edited by: joe at travelpage ]
Can you imagine this ugly thing in NCL colors. If Star does by the ships I hope they either totally redesign them for NCL, or places them with their Asian brands.
Britanis, you just wrote my post for me. I really, really want to love this ship, for patriotic reasons, but it just doesn't make it aesthetically.
Everything forward of the lifeboats needs to be redone. That seven-deck stretch of balconies is too tall, and the area forward of that - the front of the superstructure, plus the sides all the way forward, with those wide rectangular cutouts - looks like a multistory car park.
Lloyd Werft wins AMCV completion
LLOYD Werft, the German repair and conversion specialist, is planning to complete at least one of the two 72,000-GT cruise ships left unfinished at US shipyard Ingalls after the bankruptcy of American Classic Voyages. The news has been confirmed by Lloyd Werft MD Werner Lüken. The Bremerhaven yard is the "house yard" of Star Cruises subsidiary Norwegian Cruise Line, which is reportedly involved in the revival project and took on the similar-sized Norwegian Sky after its completion by Lloyd Werft in 1999. The hull of the Sky originated from an order cancelled by Costa Crociere at Bremer Vulkan, which had to halt the construction because of its financial collapse. Lloyd Werft will be short of work in the second half of this year after it completes the conversion of a bulker into a juice carrier and a frigate overhaul. Last year Lloyd Werft also completed the 78,309-GT Norwegian Sun for NCL, the hull for which was sub-ordered at Aker MTW yard as Lloyd Werft does not have hull-building facilities.
It looks like this might happen...
quote:Originally posted by Thad:It looks like this might happen...
I don't see why it wouldn't. Star/NCL are in great need of new tonnage. They need all the new ships they can get, because many of their ships right now are in desperate need of replacement.
I figure I would try my hand at Photoshop as well. I think that the ship looks better than she did as America, but still could use a longer bow
So, they are trying to get the new ship(s) from any cheaper$$$ ways. Or get money from stock market in Hong Kong or Singapore.
I think "Project America" is the best choice for Star Cruises. Although ships look like a car park, but they have more balconies and with her nice size, it is easy to enter Chinese Market which they expect to bring at least one new ship to there.
quote:Originally posted by Thad:And it could look like this:I figure I would try my hand at Photoshop as well. I think that the ship looks better than she did as America, but still could use a longer bow
Good Photoshopping (Is there such a word ?), Thad. I must say that is one ugly vessel and altough I really want to be sad that they will not be American I can't help but hope they go to China and we never have to see the things again.
Brian
Ðraikar
However, changing the hull design is very expensive and requires computer and model testing to ensure stability. If Star is strapped for money they may just accept the normal hull design.
quote:Originally posted by Draikar:It would be very odd if she sunk while under tow to a shipyard for completion.Ðraikar
Yes, but it would be more profitable to scuttle the finished ship.
quote:Originally posted by skyej:I read today that the hull is not complete- it is missing the bow and stern. If Star/NCL does buy it they may still have the option of changing the shape to make it more attractive.However, changing the hull design is very expensive and requires computer and model testing to ensure stability. If Star is strapped for money they may just accept the normal hull design.
The hull is not so bad. It is the superstructure, notably the fore part.
It just doesn't look like a coherant design, and is probably rhe result of the commitee design approach used so frequently today. If you look at the Dolphin IV and The Emerald, you'll see what I'm talking about in regard to "overbuilding" on existing hulls.
if either of the Project Americas ships are completed in a foreign shipyard, that would mean they could not sail from one American port to another, right?
Wouldn't it make more sense for NCL/Star to go ahead and finish the vessel in the states? That way they could do-away with that ridiculous run to Fanning Island on their Hawaii route. It would also put them in a position to offer other cruises between American ports that no othe line can currently offer.
The best thing AMCV had going for them (besides the Independence) was their Hawaii-intensive itinerary!
quote:Originally posted by Namlit:if either of the Project Americas ships are completed in a foreign shipyard, that would mean they could not sail from one American port to another, right?
Right.
quote:Originally posted by Namlit:Wouldn't it make more sense for NCL/Star to go ahead and finish the vessel in the states?
Not unless they wanted to pay lots and lots of taxes to have the ship U.S. registered, and to have all U.S. officers, and 75% of the crew as either U.S. citizens or green card holders - all this is very expensive.
quote:Originally posted by origo:Star Cruises also has a regulation to only have Scandinavian marine officers and I don't think that US unions would accept a Scandinavian captain on a US flagged ship .
Actually I think that all US flagged ships must have all US officers. Crew must be 75% US citizens or residents i.e. 'green card' holders.
There would be a political cyclone in Washington if a foreign company were able to run a US-flagged ship...
Ultimate Bulletin BoardTM 6.1.0.3
More Vacation & Cruise Specials...